Showing posts with label Venture Capital. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Venture Capital. Show all posts

Thursday, December 6, 2012

Applying innovations to life sciences investment


During a recent panel at Partnering for Cures, experts discussed the financing gap in life sciences and spotlighted varying perspectives on the “VC retreat” and the need to apply innovative financial and operational models to finding and funding science that holds the promise of helping patients. Renowned leaders in investment deliberated challenges in the life sciences eco-system and challenges that prevent life sciences from becoming a better investment sector. Panelists candidly shared varying points of view – from finding the incentive to kill bad experiments to the pros and cons of collecting big data.

Jens Eckstein of SR One, GlaxoSmithKline’s independent healthcare venture capital organization, noted that “syndication is the biggest problem we are facing in the early stages.” Eckstein argued that a major issue in bioscience today is that “things go to the clinic that should never go to the clinic,” with little incentive, both from academia and pharma, to kill inefficient and bad projects. As a result, he said, an inefficient system with little change in attrition in clinical development over the past 20 years has developed, creating a more difficult investment climate for everyone. Eckstein also argued that sample size and finding individuals to curate data in a useful manner are tasks still too big to tackle.

Alastair J.J. Wood of Symphony Capital echoed Eckstein’s comments, stating “I think the current [development] model is fundamentally broken.” Wood hailed a new approach to drug development that mirrors the distributed partnering model mentioned in FasterCures’ Fixes in Financing report. Wood believes that the status quo of picking winners, as pharma tends to do, is fundamentally flawed and argued that without changing the system to spread risk adequately, there is no means of attracting new capital. On data sharing, Wood was more optimistic than Eckstein, calling for the availability of pre-clinical data and the usefulness it will provide in determining the effectiveness of compounds and viability of new drugs on the market.

Likewise, Garen Staglin of One Mind for Research and Dan Hartman of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation also saw huge potential in data sharing and stressed the importance of public-private partnerships and the need to bring individuals together. “By bringing people together, we have a shorter distance to go,” noted Hartman. Staglin stated that the key for developing cures can be found in bringing different sectors together and creating stronger collaboration. “Incidence rate of illnesses do not know geographic boundaries nor does the science that will help us unlock it,” he said. Hartman agreed, noting that “with access to data, we decide where to put money for products that actually help people.”

Moderator Chris Varma of Blueprint Medicine asked a poignant question: If the product development cycle is shorter in other fields, such as IT, and prediction methods to better estimate outcomes are so much better in other fields, why do we still invest in life sciences? Eckstein gave a response that summed up the feelings of the panelists: “If things work, we can make a tremendous difference.” With the right collaboration, resources, investment, and the right optimism, science has the capability to achieve amazing things.

Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Who decided that “top 10” lists should have 10 things on them?

By Kristin Schneeman, Program Director, FasterCures

For five years now FasterCures has been producing its “Top 10” list of medical research trends to watch in the coming year. And every year we have to go through the painful process of deciding what to leave on the cutting room floor.

We relish the opportunity to tell people about some of the interesting trends, ideas, initiatives, events, and people that we think are worthy of attention in the 12 months ahead. But there is more that we’re thinking about, of course. The Top 10 list tends to be focused on things that we think are likely to be the subject of action or debate over the coming year, but there remain big, critical issues that span across years for all of us to focus on and work on together.

We’re concerned about the financial sustainability of the whole research enterprise. We’re hearing that venture capital is fleeing from life sciences, and those who are sticking around are investing in less risky opportunities. We’ll be fortunate if government funding remains flat – we’re not predicting any big increases in the current fiscal environment. So if more money isn’t likely to be pouring into the system anytime soon, what new sources of funding are out there, and what new financial models might be applied? Could constrained resources be an impetus for greater focus and efficiency in the research process?

The “business model” of university innovation is changing, and we’re working to understand the landscape of new approaches to commercializing university inventions: Who are the new partners? What are the new sources of capital? Do we have the human capital needed? What are the new intellectual property policies? When is the right time to license?

We’re interested in what appears to be an increasing openness on the part of big pharma to the need for new business models of their own, not just doing things better the same old way. They’re groping their way toward it – embracing more truly “open innovation,” more pre-competitive collaboration, new ways of interacting with academia, working more closely with patient groups – but the pressure is on to “evolve or die.”

Supporting and improving the FDA will continue to be a major focus for us. We’d like to see FDA be able to better leverage NIH’s research capacity to improve its ability to evaluate the new science coming down the pipeline. We’d like to see the Reagan-Udall Foundation established on firm footing so it can become the kind of resource that the Foundation for the NIH has become for the NIH. We’d like to see more patient-driven research foundations engaging in a conversation with FDA about patients’ needs and priorities. And we’ll be doing our best to ensure a productive public dialogue about the role and record of FDA; a “blame game” doesn’t serve any of us well.

As if our mission weren’t ambitious enough, we’re also considering how the states on either end of the medical R&D continuum – prevention/wellness and the delivery of care – fit in with our work to improve the system that discovers and develops treatments for disease. And we are considering what the impact of an increasingly global research enterprise, as well as global sources of capital, could have on the U.S. biomedical research system.

With so much work to be done, there is no time to waste!